Knowing the System Isn’t the Same as Running the System

I’ve been writing professionally for decades. I’ve written more than 200 books, and I’ve written an entire book about how to be a productive fiction writer. You’d think I’d have this productivity business figured out by now.

Apparently not.

A little while ago, I mentioned to my husband that I was feeling stressed. He was baffled. Things were going well. My agent was submitting books to publishers, I’d just written a short story I was particularly pleased with, and several other professional developments were looking promising. What on earth did I have to be stressed about?

It took me a while to figure it out. I’d spent the entire morning dealing with stuff. Emails, messages, administrative tasks, unexpected requests, industry developments, decisions that needed making, and a dozen minor irritations. None of them was particularly disastrous. Most were perfectly ordinary parts of running a writing business. But each demanded a little piece of my attention.

And each time I switched from one thing to another, I had to abandon whatever I’d been thinking about, deal with the new issue, then find my way back.

I called it attention pinball.

By lunchtime, I was exhausted, irritated, and convinced things were slipping through the cracks. Worst of all, I hadn’t written.

The Mystery of the Self-Washing Dishes

The previous day had been completely different. I’d received an opportunity to submit a short story to an anthology, and decided to go for it. I developed the idea, plotted the story, wrote it, and revised it, all in one day.

I was so deeply absorbed that I barely registered anything happening around me. My husband washed an entire day’s worth of dishes and cooked dinner. My daughter made grilled cheese sandwiches and put one beside me. I noticed the sandwich. I ate it.

I did not notice the dishes.

In fact, after dinner, I got up, mentally girding myself to tackle the enormous pile of washing-up, only to discover it had mysteriously disappeared.

My family assured me they hadn’t been particularly quiet about any of this. Apparently, my brain had decided that everything unrelated to the story was irrelevant.

The interesting thing was that I’d written the story in my usual recliner, in the middle of the household. The same place where I’d spent the following morning being distracted by absolutely everything.  Clearly, the recliner wasn’t the problem.  Nor was my ability to concentrate.  I could concentrate perfectly well when I gave myself permission to do it.

So what had changed?

When Writing Time Stops Being Writing Time

For years, my preferred writing schedule has been 6:30 to 9:30 in the morning. Three hours, first thing, before the rest of the working day gets underway. I know this schedule works for me. I’ve used it successfully for years.

Except, when I examined what I’d actually been doing lately, I realized that 6:30 to 9:30 had gradually become something more like: I’ll try to write in the morning, unless something else needs attention.

And there was always something else. An email that seemed important. A message that deserved an answer. A business problem that needed solving. An interesting publishing development. A new idea that seemed more urgent than the book I was supposed to be writing.

Sometimes the distractions were genuinely important. Sometimes they were simply interesting. And sometimes they were perfectly legitimate professional work that happened to be easier or more immediately rewarding than writing the next chapter.

I hadn’t consciously abandoned my writing routine. I’d simply allowed so many exceptions that the routine barely existed anymore.

This was an uncomfortable realization, because I’ve spent years telling other writers to protect their writing time.

I knew all the principles. I’d written about them extensively. I just wasn’t following them.

The Return of the Slugs

I decided to reinstate the original boundary. From 6:30 to 9:30, I would write fiction. Not check email. Not work on the business. Not research an interesting publishing question. Not develop the next book while avoiding the current one.

Write.

I also realized that my husband couldn’t reasonably be expected to know when I was writing. I work in a recliner in our living room. From across the room, I look exactly the same whether I’m writing a novel, answering email, researching something, or wasting time on the internet.

Sometimes, in the past, I’d been available for conversation during those hours. Sometimes I hadn’t. How was he supposed to know the difference?

So I started announcing it. “I’m writing until 9:30. I’m about to go Do Not Disturb. Is there anything you need before I raise shields?”

Then I put in my earbuds. My husband calls them the slugs in my ears. The slugs became my ON AIR sign.

And something rather wonderful happened. He stopped interrupting me.  Not because he suddenly became silent or stopped doing things around the house, but because he understood that I wasn’t available for conversation.

When something occurred to him, he left me a message on Discord to read later.

The first morning I finished writing, I pulled out the earbuds and sat up. He immediately asked, “So, how did it go?” He knew I’d stopped writing. We’d managed to establish a clear boundary without rearranging the household or requiring everyone to tiptoe around me.

The Other Person Who Kept Interrupting Me

Unfortunately, my husband wasn’t the only source of interruptions. I was.  I’d remember something that needed doing and immediately go and do it. I’d encounter an interesting book recommendation and spend twenty minutes investigating the author.

I’d think of a business issue and decide that I might as well deal with it while it was fresh in my mind.

Each of these seemed harmless. But they all involved abandoning the manuscript and switching mental gears. So I reinstated another old practice: capture, don’t process.

When something occurs to me during writing time, I make a quick note. That’s all. I don’t research it, solve it, organize it, or turn it into a project. After 9:30, I can review the notes and decide what needs attention.

Some things become tasks. Some can wait. And some turn out not to have been particularly important in the first place. The critical thing is that I no longer have to interrupt the writing to reassure myself that I won’t forget something.

I also had to stop a more insidious form of interruption. While drafting, my brain kept insisting that the story wasn’t working. The pacing was wrong. Nothing was happening. This scene was dragging. Perhaps I should stop and figure out what was wrong.

I recognized that trap, too.

Drafting and evaluating are different activities. Constantly switching between them can destroy momentum.  So I kept writing.  If the story genuinely needed fixing, I could fix it later.

And Then There Was Ceridwen

There was one more thing I decided to resurrect. A writing ritual. [More about rituals here and here.]

Now, I’ve spent years rolling my eyes at writers who solemnly describe lighting candles, invoking their muse, and preparing their sacred writing space. For heaven’s sake. Just write the book.

Except I used to have a ritual myself. It even included a homemade ode to Ceridwen, the Welsh goddess associated with inspiration and poetic wisdom.

I’d gradually stopped using it. And now I realized that perhaps those earnest writers I’d been quietly mocking had understood something useful.

A ritual doesn’t have to be mystical. It can simply be a reliable signal to your brain that it’s time to switch activities.  The same sequence, repeated regularly, can help establish a mental association between the ritual and the work that follows.

I didn’t need to believe Ceridwen was going to descend from the heavens and dictate the next chapter. I just needed to take the ritual seriously enough to use it consistently.

The ritual was an attention switch.

And after several years of increasingly porous boundaries, I could use one.

The Results Were Rather Embarrassing

On the first morning of my restored writing routine, I wrote 5,124 words. On the second, 4,100. On the third, a little over 4,000.

Roughly 13,000 words in three mornings. All while sitting in the same recliner, in the same household, with the same people going about their usual business.

Naturally, by the third morning, I was complaining that my productivity was declining. Apparently, writing more than 4,000 words before breakfast wasn’t good enough anymore.

But the word counts weren’t really the important result. What mattered was that I’d written for three consecutive mornings without allowing the rest of the world to commandeer the time.

And when 9:30 arrived, I could open my email, check my messages, and deal with the day’s obligations without the miserable background awareness that I still hadn’t written. The writing was done. Anything else I accomplished that day was a bonus.

The Problem Was Process Drift

Once I got over being annoyed with myself, I realized something important. I hadn’t forgotten how to be productive. And the methods I’d been advocating for years hadn’t stopped working.

I’d stopped using them properly.

Not deliberately. My routines had simply drifted. A small exception here. A reasonable accommodation there. A new responsibility. A changed circumstance. A habit quietly abandoned because it didn’t seem essential anymore.

None of those changes was significant enough to notice at the time. But over months and years, they’d accumulated. The system I thought I was using was no longer the system I was actually using.

And I suspect this happens to experienced writers more often than we realize. We establish working methods that suit us. We become comfortable with them. We stop thinking about how they work. Then life changes, and we adapt. Sometimes those adaptations are improvements. Sometimes they’re compromises.

And sometimes they’re little leaks that gradually drain the effectiveness out of a perfectly good routine.

Because the changes happen slowly, we don’t necessarily recognize what’s going wrong. We simply notice that writing seems harder than it used to be, that we’re getting less done, or that our working days feel increasingly chaotic.

We might conclude that we need a new productivity system, when what we actually need is to examine the one we already have.

When Did You Last Audit Your Writing Process?

This is what I’d encourage you to do, particularly if you’re an experienced writer whose productivity isn’t what it used to be. Take a good look at how you actually work. Not how you think you work.

Not how you worked five years ago. How you work today.

  • What did your original routine look like? Which parts made it effective? What has changed?
  • Which changes were deliberate improvements, and which were simply accommodations that became permanent?
  • Have you gradually allowed interruptions into time that used to be protected?
  • Are you still following the routines you believe you’re following?
  • And are there boundaries that have become so loose they’re barely boundaries at all?

The goal isn’t necessarily to return to some idealized version of your working life from ten years ago. Your circumstances may be entirely different now. Mine certainly are.

The point is to identify what still works, what no longer serves you, and what needs tightening up.

Sometimes that will mean designing a new process. But sometimes it means nothing more complicated than taking up the slack in the hawsers and bringing your working practices back to where you intended them to be.

Knowing the system isn’t the same as running the system.

And even a very good system needs occasional maintenance.

One Final Irony

Just as I was congratulating myself on having restored my writing routine, I moved my writing sessions from the living-room recliner to my desktop computer. Which means the environment has changed again.

Now I have to figure out how to establish the boundaries in the new location.

Reviewing and adjusting your working processes isn’t something you do once and then forget about.

Apparently, I forgot that, too.  😊

Now Available.

The Anti-Ensh*ttification Field Manual for Indie Authors:
Because the platforms will decay…but your career doesn’t have to go down with them.

Now Available.

The Indie Author Survival Guide
How to Stay Profitable, Productive and Sane in a Tougher Market

Now Available.

Productive Indie Fiction Writer cover

The Productive Indie Fiction Writer: Strategies for Writing More, Earning More, and Living Well

Write More, Faster Than Ever Before | Are You Prolific?

Editing Your Next Novel? Mark Posey offers fast, writer-friendly edits with zero drama. Check out services »

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top